I disagree, in theory there is no reason but in reality there is. The Twins and Mets tried to tell Gomez to think first and then react, well it took him too long to think and he struggled. The Brewers told him to react first and think later, and he could stop focusing on analyzing every situation and just go with his instincts...and now he is an elite player. You are basically saying you would tell him: CarGo, whenever there is a situation that you might make an aggressive mistake, stop to think if you will likely make the mistake, but in situation where you will not make an aggressive mistake, then don't think about those situations. I don't think the Twins & Mets told him to think before reacting. The way they held him back was telling him to focus on being a contact line drive/groundball hitter. What the Brewers did was to allow him to be more free-swinging. He seems to be about the same player he ever was, in terms of defense & baserunning -- all out at all times.