I considered some of these guys. Braggs, James and Belliard spent a lot of time in the majors, so while their careers were disappointing, it's not like they didn't do anything. True. But I tried to base things on hype/disappointment ratio. In doing so, I wasn't really fair to Tim McIntosh, as he wasn't really hyped too much with Surhoff in the fold. I'm going to go with Darrell Porter at catcher. He did make an all star team, but was largely a disappointment who developed drug/alcohol issues in Milwaukee. From what I've read, he was going to be the next Johnny Bench, an all-world H.S. athlete coming out of high school in Oklahoma. As a matter of fact, around the time of his debut, I've read that the Orioles offered a trade package including Dave McNally (who had several 20 win seasons at that time). The Brewers said no, kept Porter, he developed said personal problems and eventually was given to Kansas City where he finally developed into a good player.