Why the hatred for TGJ? I think that first of all, he's a rookie and we can look for him to improve upon his performance this season rather then the other way around. He doesn't look overmatched, but rather is confident at the plate and puts up great at-bats, he can run, he can play defense, and I for one would love to have him get one hit a night at the top of the lineup. As has been stated, you give a little with Gwynn with offensive production from the right-field position in terms of extra base hits, but gain production over the league norm at shortstop with Hardy, CF with Hall (hopefully), Estrada at catcher, and at 2b with Rickie if he plays up to his potential. A decent trade-off I would say.