By no means am I a Counsell fan, but I would take him over Lamb platooning with Hall any day - especially defensively. And I don't necessarily think that 3rd base is going to be a platoon. I really think Hall is going to step up and take the reins this year. Plus Counsell looks rejuinated now that he has a normal stance and has his hands down where they should be. So then you have Counsell to back up at 3rd, SS, and 2nd. And if you are of the opinion like I am that Duffy and Nelson are going to be the 2 backup outfielders it would make sense to have another righty on the bench when the predominantly right handed normal starting lineup is out there because your only RH PH option on those days is Rivera if McGehee doesn't make the team. So IMO McGehee making the roster makes a ton of sense; especially seeing he has some pop. And I don't get the sense that Macha has been real impressed with Lamb - I know I sure haven't been. He looks old, stiff and slow.