Let's start with the numbers. Impressive power. Good average. Poor fielder. If Braun's numbers are prorated over a season (since he did not come up to the Brewers until late May), he could be considered the most productive first year slugger ever, could beat McGwire's rookie homer record of 49. But on actual comparison with Tulo-witzki, going into Sunday's games, judging the whole season and not some fanciful projection of it, Tulowitzki has more RBI, more runs scored, more hits, a respectable total of home runs and a range and arm at shortstop that anchors the best fielding team in the league. Not to mention, and this seems never to be mentioned, an unassisted triple play. No, in real time, over a whole season, there is very little to choose with what each has done, but the edge must go to Tulowitzki, who is also a year younger than Braun. But if the judgment comes just because there was a movie - mostly unseen, but still . . . - actually called The Hebrew Hammer, let us offer one called Troy, not to recommend either. The movies, not the ballplayers. Tulo-witzki is the clear choice there. I mean this guy could not possibly be more of a home town writer even if he tried. I like how mentions all the stats where Tulo leads, but fails to mention stolen bases, BA, OBP, SLG, etc. etc. Tulo is a terrific player but he'll be second in voting when the time comes.