You have it just the opposite. If his name was John Smith, there wouldn't be the venom towards him by some there is here. He would be seen as what he is, a low power, more speed good defensive OF, with the potential to hit for a decent average. There have been hundreds of thsoe guys in MLB over the decades who've made nice careers, many of whom were starters at some time or another. He's a good defender and a natural CF. He's not a great base stealer but he has well above average speed. The two biggest knocks on him are lack of power and a relatively low OBP. Yet the last time he was a full time player, he had respectable .360/.396 at Nashville, better than his numbers in lower minors. His major league numbers are insignificant because they are small sample and compiled over sporadic ABs. He is absolutely the logical choice to fill in. Not only will he give you much better defense than having Gross in right and Hart in center, by having him get 100 or so consistent major league AB's the Brewers will have a much better read on his potential than they do now. As for his power lacking, that is the last thing that this team is lacking.