I basically agree with everything here, although I think Kotsay may be a better PH than Boggs. However, I would probably rather have Boggs start over Kotsay. My big problem with Kotsay is his defense (or lack thereof) and the fact that he has been playing so often. He's fine for a 5th outfielder and pinch-hitter but shouldn't be playing as much as he has been. I don't see a reason to baby Hart like some do. At this point, he should be ready to go. I also don't think people are over-exaggerating how bad Kotsay is. Everyone basically accepts the fact that he can draw a walk and hit the occasional single or double but he has no power and no defense. A guy like that shouldn't be starting as much as he has. I do also wonder what Doug and Roenicke like so much about Kotsay? Why both seem to think he's a better player than Boggs? Yea, Kotsay has a very solid approach at the plate by generally working the count and not just being a hacker, but so does Boggs. Hell, last year in AAA he drew 72 walks in only 439 at bats. He had 14 walks in only 60 at bats this year at Nashville for a .500 OBP after posting a .402 OBP the previous year in OKC. Boggs can switch hit. He's better defensively. While Boggs isn't exactly a power hitter, he certainly has more power than Kotsay. So what am i missing here? Once Morgan gets back, i'm pretty sure that Boggs will get DFA and Kotsay won't play much assuming none of the four main outfielders don't suffer a significant injury. That said, i still won't like or understand the decision to keep Kotsay over Boggs even if there likely won't be any sort of big impact on the team either way unless the injury bug strikes the outfield.