For as flawed as defensive metrics are, especially in small samples like 31 games is, i have no problem with using my eyes to deduce that this is a below average defensive team at best. I can look at the guys who play everyday or nearly everyday and see that the only very clear plus defender out there is Gomez. On the infield, Prince, Yuni, and Casey are all below average defensively. Braun is below average. Hart is better than Braun at judging balls off the bat, but his arm is very inaccurate. So there is no way that a team can be so lacking in plus defenders while having multiple below average defenders, and somewhere be an average defensive team. I do think though that all the shifts we use has helped the defense overall by preventing more would be hits than the shifts have turned would be outs into hits. As for fixing or helping the defense, i don't see much that Doug can do at this point. None of Prince, Weeks, Braun, and Hart have any chance of being traded. McGehee is only making about 550,000 dollars, good luck trying to find a better overall option for thirdbase at that price. Gomez is easily our best defensive player. Maybe at some point Melvin could try trading for a better shortstop, but we have few trade chips left in the minors and odds are nobody is going to consider trading players until around the deadline. We'll likely be shuffling some pitchers up and down from the minors during the year, but until the deadline at least, odds are high that from a position player stance, this is the team that the Brewers will sink or swim with.