It's more the fact that Lawrie - remember he compared himself to Russell Martin - was initially very enthusiastic about playing catcher, and decided to quit the position after one set of instructionals, ostensibly not because it was too difficult for him, but because it was too much work. Now, why would a player want to be a catcher? A player with Lawrie's projected offensive tools would be a perennial contender for the all-star game. He could have been truly exceptional at that position. Obviously I don't know if the whole catching experiment would have succeeded, but it does bother me that he didn't try harder to shoot for the moon. This, coupled with a plethora of other negative comments about his work ethic, has me a little worried. DHonks, you're right about Gindl - and don't get me wrong, there's plenty to love about getting a mediocre starter. As far as Gamel, yeah I think there's no doubt the team has mishandled him. At the same time he's shown a penchance for getting injured at the wrong times, and he too has been plagued by whispers of attitude problems.