I don't agree with Melvin leaving but that's another topic. You have the underlying issue right on though. The hitters are who they are (I really hate that cliche, I wish I thought of a different one). They are not going to magically change with a new hitting coach or manager. In the end I think the offense will be fine. It amazes me how many think that you can just "coach em up" and get different results. To me the hitting coach has to be one of the most pointless positions on a club. I think they can be valuable studying film of the player to find subtle changes in the hands or stance that have changed, but as far as actually coaching on a daily basis to try to change an approach to me that's fruitless. The time to instill an approach to hitting is in the minor leagues. Let me back up a bit by saying I have no idea what a MLB hitting coach or Svuem does on a daily basis, perhaps that's what he/they do, in which case it would still be pointless to swap him out. I think if I was hitting coach I'd just string together some highlights of each player hitting well and have them watch for 15 minutes before the game. IMO, the two biggest problems on this club are infield defense and our bench. I realize we aren't swapping out our whole infield, but I still think it would make a huge difference to somehow get a guy at short to replace Yuni even if he's only a defensive whizz. We have the pitching this year, but having them wonder if every ground ball will be booted or second guessing an attempt to try to get a hitter to ground into a DP will make the staff less effective. Secondly, our bench provides zero value to this team. I know most teams don't have an elite bench but usually theres some reason why they're on the team. I realize there's been some injuries to deal with but guys like Nieves, Kotsay, Almonte shouldn't have a spot on this team. There are better options. Gamel, Kottaras, Boggs, Katin. If Yuni was replaced he'd actually have some value on the bench, as at least he can put the ball in play consistently and has a bit of power.