When I think of Soup, I think of game 4 of the 2008 NLDS. That decision to start Soup over Yo in game 4 of the 2008 NLDS bothered me greatly then and even now. I hated that decision when it was annouced, I definitely would've started Yo in a must win game over Soup and it's not even a tough call. As it turns out, Soup gave up 5 ERs in 3 innings before being yanked out of the game, Yo replaced him and pitched 3 shutout innings giving up only 1 hit. The Philles went on to win the game 6-2, and the world series. I think we could have won game 4 if we had started Yo instead, and CC was scheduled to pitch game 5. After 26 years, it would've been great to win a playoff series... That decision to start Soup over Yo has to the worst decision in Sveum's managerial career, I still don't understand why he did it.