No it was not. I'm sorry but that is insane. "By a lot"? Come on, give me a break. You're up by 3 points in the second half, at your own 29, you punt the ball. He gave us a 30 yard field and we scored in 2 plays. If that's analytically correct, analytics are broken. You would rightfully lose your mind on MLF if he did something that stupid and it didn't work. Yes I'm sure your odds of converting 4th and 1 are greater than 50%, but you can't just say it's the correct call and ignore all the situational variables.