I'm a debbie downer on the Brewers with the best of them but this thread takes the cake. I was no fan of Villar, but he was done here and it was time for him to go. If he turns into an all-star so be it. Oritz has some potential but spent 3 years at AA and seems like he can't stay healthy. Honestly never even heard of Carmona but teenage international signings are such crapshoots you have no clue what he might or might not be. Is he Gilbert Lara or Jose Ramirez? Schoop has pretty much sucked since he got here, there's no denying that. But considering the blackhole that was our middle infield all year long and he can retained next year, seems like an acceptable trade to me. It's not like Schoop is keeping a better player off the field at this point and his ceiling is definitely high than Perez, Saladino, Orf, Sogard and whatever other crap we were running out there.