This is just wrong and a horrible use of statistics. 37-24 = .607 59-42 = .584 You replace Zack and Marcum with some AAA/vet scrubs and that team does not make the playoffs. That team is the same team it was the years prior that could put lots of runs on the board but couldn't stop the other team from doing the same thing. I still don't think the 2014 team would be all that better without the Greinke trade. Khris Davis and Cain put up almost identical OPS+ (108 for Davis, 107 for Cain). I understand that Cain is better than Davis because of his defense (or Khris's lack of) but with both of these guys on the team there are 4 RHB outfielders. Cain isn't starting over Gomez or Braun, so either Khris or Lorenzo is in AAA or traded. I'm not a huge fan of Segura but so far he has outhit Escobar in his career. Even if you just look at Escobar's time in KC, Segura has been better (career OPS+ of 87 for Segura vs 79 for Escobar). Once again, it comes down to defense. Escobar is clearly superior over Segura. So when comparing the position players in the trade, the offense is almost a wash. The defense is a downgrade but in 2014, this team couldn't score a run to save it's life after July. Cain or Escobar probably wouldn't have changed that. The Wild Card is Odorizzi. He's looking like he might be a middle of the rotation guy. But does he become that with Milwaukee? Someone said he learned a pitch from Alex Cobb. That doesn't happen if he's a Brewer and couple that with the organization's ineptitude when it comes to developing pitchers and he's probably a backend of the rotation/bullpen pitcher. I don't know how he fits on the 2014 team. Garza probably isn't signed and if you replace Garza's 2014 numbers (163 in, 1.4 WAR, 104 ERA+) with Jake's (168 in, 1.2 WAR, 90 ERA+) you once again get a wash or slight downgrade.