This could be true. But the risk of injury a broken finger/hand, cracked rib, Concussion is there. Allowing Cardinal Pitchers to hit our batters 10times to 1 lets say means our hitters have 10times the risk of attaining those kind of injuries that may lead to a long DL stint. April 28th Brewers vs. Cardinals Brewers were 18-7 Game 1 of 3game set Carlos Gomez is hit by pitch in 6th along with ARam HBP in 6th. Top of 7th bases loaded ARam is hit by pitch again. Khris Davis drives in game winner in extras. Game 2 Lohse hits a PH G. Garcia Win 20-7 on the season. Game 3 Khris Davis(Mr GW 2 days earlier) in top of 8th inning in a 9-3 Cardinals lead is HBP Fast forward to July 11th Brewers 52-41 First Batter of the Game Gomez is HBP. Game 2. Nelson in his 2nd start of the season beaned Holliday in the 1st inning. Adam Wainwright folks. Staked to a 6-0 lead somehow Beans Carlos Gomez with 2outs in the 3rd inning. Game 3. Bottom of the 4th. Runner on 2nd base first base open who's at the Plate? Carlos Gomez. Beaned. 3game series, 3 separate games Carlos Gomez was beaned. Fast forward Aug 1st Brewers 60-49 Game 1. Top of the 6th 3-0 Brewers Adam Wainwright pitching Runners on 2nd and 3rd 1out 1st base open. Carlos Gomez to bat. Beaned Game 2. Gorzo beans Carpenter in the 8th inning Game 3. Garza Beans Matt Adams leading off the 2nd inning in a 2-0 lead for Milw. Fast forward Sept 4th Brewers 73-66 Game 1 Peralta beaned Holliday and Scruggs Game 2 Bot 7th 1out 6-2Brewers lead. Lyons Beans Lucroy Game 3 Lohse beans Lynn in 2nd. Lynn Beans Overbay in 4th Game 4 No HBP All told HBPs its: Gomez 5 ARam 2 Lucroy/Davis 1 Holliday 2 Adams 1. Oh the final Series No beanings by Cardinal Pitchers. Hey they had a 5game lead and Playoff Bound. ARam's 2HBPs led to him missing the 2nd/3rd games of that series. He'd return to the lineup after the series for 8 of the next 9 games and bats 5-29 only to suffer a strained Hamstring and miss the next 22games. Gomez didn't come away affected from his 5 beanings. Yadier Molina not beaned once in the season series. Neither was Braun but he's not the Braun of old. Anyway, just my reasoning of why I didn't like Roenicke's non retailiate tactics. Gomez gets beaned 5 times twice by the Ace of the Cardinal Staff! Someone who hbp batters 4 times one year in 230IP and last season 6 total times in 241IP! Yet batting in the 3rd in a 6-0winning game and 1b open with 1out in a 3-0losing game he beaned Gomez twice. 2 of his 7Hit Batters were Gomez in nearly 900Batters faced. And I'm sure this has Molina/Cardinal way all over it. Just giving reference to my suggestion. Whatever your personal feelings are on retaliation, I think it is quite apparent that the Cardinals have no fear of pitching inside, throwing at our batters, or flat out hitting them. Apparently, Grandpa Ken's strongly worded letter to the commissioner a few years ago had no affect on them.