Yes, ever since his breakout season in 2009 we had all these people saying that his success was a fluke, and it seems like no matter how long McGehe continues to be successful we will still have all these haters. Even after easily being in top quarter of offensive 3rd baseman in all of MLB in 2010, and at the league minimum salary, we have people making posts about replacing him, and some folks agreeing that he doesn't have enough pop in his bat for a 3rd baseman. Last year McGehe hit 25 homeruns (5th among MLB 3B), and had 104 RBI (2nd among MLB 3B), and an OPS of .801 (3rd among MLB 3B). If you look at the players ranking ahead of him offensively, they are all making millions and millions of dollars (ARod, Beltre, Wright, Longoria, Zimmerman). One could argue that on a cash strapped team McGehe offers more value right now (and next year) than any of these guys. The amount that McGehe earns allows us to get high level of production at 3B while saving money for an upgrade at SS next year. The defense leaves a little to be desired but is more than made up for with the bat and low salary.