I'd go 7/161 (23 million a year with 5 million deferred annually (comes to 18 million a year)), 25 million 8th year mutual option W/ 10 million buyout, with an opt out after 3 years. Total guaranteed comes to $171 million, and potentially $186 million. A few points, 1.) Fielder will be 34 years old by the last year of the contract. He's currently 27. 2.) I don't see any team giving him 8 years guaranteed. I can see a team offering 25 million for 7 years (175 million) guaranteed. Which is more money than the Brewers, but at least the Brewers offer would be competitive, and they would be putting Fielder in a position where he would have to choose to stay in Milwaukee, where he would be apart of one of the best hitting combos (Braun, Fielder) in Baseball history, a team that can provide him protection in the line-up (Weeks), a contending team that just won the division, excellent fan base, or choose an extra 5-15 million dollars and play for a new team. 3.) The Brewers are going to find out (perhaps they already are) that they will likely be outbid when it comes to players like Reyes, Pujols, Rollins etc.. Which will imo force them to go hard after Fielder and increase their offer to him. They will also know that the Brewers offense will be down graded without Fielder and that Braun won't have the same protection behind him. For these reasons the Brewers have to still be interested in Fielder, and I think what we have seen is the Brewers just being smart by exploring other alternatives first, because Fielder is a long term risk due to his weight and the money he will demand, but regardless it will likely lead back to Fielder, in my opinion. 4.) If Fielder chooses to play for a new team, then I can see the Brewers just plugging holes with players like Alex Gonzales at SS and Ramirez at 3B and McGehee/Gamel 1B. The Brewers probably have fall back options, but regardless their offense will take a significant hit, because they are minus a premium player.