nate82...both statistically and with the eye-check Scooter is far and away better than Weeks. Scooter got to so many balls last year that Weeks wouldn't have. I found myself continually thinking "wow, how is it we weren't told to expect this good of defense?!?!?" After years of having a DH play 2b, it was refreshing to see someone with range, footwork, throwing accuracy, and solid throwing mechanics. Plus, for nearly a decade I cringed and held my breath on every bunt, as I knew that it would mean Rickie covering 1st base. I think I still have nightmares of decent throws up the line--catchable throws--flying into the right field corner as Weeks steps away from the base.