The average that flirts with the Mendoza line... But like I said before, bearable when he's hitting for power. He didn't have a reputation as a good defender, but has been pretty darn good this season. It's a nice little discussion to have. If a guy gets 400 ABs over the course of a year ... the difference between a .200 hitter and a .250 hitter is 20 hits. His career OBP is .326 .. which isn't shocking and considering the BA is actually really good. Are you willing to sacrifice that average for the power he gives you? If you are asking him to bat in the middle of the lineup and get 600 PAs I would argue not. But hitting in the bottom of a lineup? I would actually call him an asset. If his defense historically has been what we are watching now ... I don't understand why a minor league deal was the best he could do ... he seems like a pretty good platoon option almost anywhere. Pretty much agree with all of this. I will not be voting Reynolds onto any all-star team. If DM can find an upgrade over him, great. However I don't feel any urgent need to replace him with just anybody. If DM were to do something crazy in the off season, like acquire two all-star corner infielders, I would still offer Reynolds a major league deal. His power would be great off the bench.