David, you're the only guy I know who will complain about a quality start. Most of your complaints are warrented, but not this one. 6IP, 3 runs is a quality start. It also is a pitcher with a 4.50ERA and not every start will be a quality start. My comments were that Kinney has the stuff to be a very good starter, but it seems in every game he falls asleep or loses concentration and he gives up a bunch of runs. Compared to Sheets and several other pitchers with similar numbers, Matt gives up many more multiple run innings than other pitchers. He can go most of the game without making mistakes, then when 1 happens, he gets unnerved, then another happens, and before you know it he's given up 3 runs. That's not a physical problem, it's a mental problem. If he didn't have the ability to be a better pitcher I wouldn't mind so much, but we've all seen that he has some good stuff. Maybe a light will go on, maybe not, but as he is he's a #5 starter.