In the last 2 years, I don't see much of a chance given at all. 75 PA in 2012? 148 PA back in '09. When you're out with an injury, there is no chance. This is a guy who hit .304/.376/.498/.873 with 105 HR in 7 seasons in the minors. 28 home runs back in 2011. The guy had ACL tears, not shoulder tears. He still should be able to hit. Pretty sure a damaged/repaired ACL does, infact, impact how someone swings at the plate. your feet are planted but your knees still twist when you swing a bat.