Except Gamel was left handed too and he was going to be the 5th outfielder once Hart returned. I imagine Davis will be 5th OF until Hart returns under that scenario. I'd be okay with Carp. He wasn't all that bad in 2011, and has played some OF. Now if he has shoulder issues that prevented him from playing OF, then that's a problem. I hope Doug makes a deal for Carp... He's a Gamel clone... Bats LH and plays 1B, LF & RF.