Cool Hand Lucroy

Give him a plaque!!!

You're welcome. Although it probably bought Bauers the rest of the season, so...crap. (blue)

Completely, and it isn't really about Bauers. He is who he is, which is basically a replacement level player (at best). He is 29 and has had like 1700 ABs. When you have an above-average sitting at AAA, why are you waiting on Bauers to suddenly become Freddy Freeman? I just do not buy, in any way, the idea that it's too much to ask to carry two RH-hitting, exclusively 1B/DHs. Teams carry 3 catchers in September, man. Plus, Bauers is not really playing the OF, either. He is 1B and DH. At the very least, this club needs to do a better of arguing its case (which is impossible, because there is no serious case). Everyone can see it but Murph/the org. Again, I'm not thinking this is any kind of solution. Like I said, I don't even think it matters that much. But I would love for someone to make the case for Bauers belonging on this roster in a way that makes sense.

I mean, I don't think it matters THAT much, but at this point it seems like a clearly awful decision to have Bauers on this roster over Hoskins. This org makes so many great decisions I'm almost comforted to see them botch one so badly.

That's the goal.

Yeah...but Bauers is a LEFTY!!! (Blue) Maybe if I tag on the guy in another post, he'll finally swing the bat.

The NFL is the most popular thing in America. It's crazy how Teflon that league is. They can get caught up in scandal after scandal, hand out painkillers like they're candy, deny CTE, and generally just do whatever they want, and they'll run the world. Come to think of it, Jake Bauers is the NFL of the Milwaukee Brewers.

The only argument for Bauers is he's a lefty, and that's no good enough, especially with an extra position player spot available. If you like Siegler, fine. If you like Bauers, fine (I guess). Having both with a proven MLB bat, with slug, rotting in Triple A is...baffling. I totally trust and respect Arnold, but if this is in any way his call, it's the wrong one. Does it matter that much? I don't know. Probably depends how many more times I have to watch bad lefties take ABs from a better righty.

Obviously, we're a banged-up bunch. I think Murphy has absolutely overused Ashby, He has also leaned hard on Uribe and Koenig and Mears, even in games in which we trail. I'm not a big fan of that, but I get it in some ways. You throw out Easton Mcgee in a one-run game in the 8th, and people are going to get grumpy. It's a tough spot for a manager, up comfortably in the division/bye race, but nowhere near clinching it. Still, it's not like the Phillies dominated us. Suarez was great today, and we blew the sixth inning. Otherwise, we basically played them dead even over three games and clinched the tiebreaker. I'm not really sure how that's a disaster. It seems like mostly a fine outcome, albeit something less than we were hoping for. At this point, I'm ready for October baseball. I don't really care if we get caught if we play decent and get healthy. We were mostly fine this series. Let's be a little better in these next 15, and the rest is kind of random fluctuations of the ball.

I'll say this about Bauers: He LOOKS like he can hit. It's a nice stance.

Siegler has a tendency to play the ball off to the side? I know that was hit hard, but something about his body positioning doesn't feel right.

Kim homers to put the Braves up 3-1. Y'all reverse jinx nicely.

123 OPS+ while playing incredible defense at a premium position. What did Contreras finish last year? 5th? Turang should be up there for sure.

And check out Siegler with the warning track power!!! Almost.

I fully recognize that Harrison Bader feels a little bit like a Brewer in a dark mirror. But I really don't like Harrison Bader. Until we sign him in free agency this winter (half blue).

Like I said, I am much closer to this than where the org has landed. But the guy's getting like 8 ABs a week, right? And I don't think they're bad ABs. He has no power, but he walks, plays a couple positions, and has been a little unlucky. Obviously, I'd rather have Hoskins than Siegler, but we don't three 1B when one of them is Bauers. End of the day, alls I'm saying is I'd rather defend the Bauers out hill than the Siegler one (though I'd prefer not to have to defend any hill at all).

I can't think of many pitchers who are perfectly happy throwing 40 percent of their pitches for balls. But Q is one of them.

I sort of get Siegler. He has some versatility and fits the definition of "scrappy" or whatever that the org likes. I don't like it, but I can squint and understand the ABs at the bottom of the roster. I really dislike that he's getting starts over Durbin. I wouldn't do it. At least there's some kind of idea there, though. The best argument I can make for Bauers is handedness. That's not good enough, and him being up over Hoskins is a mistake. Aside from that, a good start to this one. Here's to 7 strong from Q and a Braves win too (as I channel my inner treego).

The answer is: next year. The Brewers want him in October. They are going to limit his innings. He'll start a middle inning clean and go one time through max. It's first-year Hader, with the idea that Miz actually will move to start. Kind of like they did with Burnes, and remember how awful his first year starting went.

Baseball drives you nuts. It never feels good to drop a game in the standings this time of year. Honestly, these times are always the most stressful. The math says you're good, but we also know the Cubs have a one in 15 shot to catch us, and that's not nothing. It's the time of year where I don't even really know what to be invested in. Just hope we win, and the rest shakes itself out. Today was a fascinating baseball game. We didn't pitch well enough to win. Or the Phillies pitched slightly less poorly. Or the Philly offense just hung in there a little better than ours. Maybe that lineup is just really darn good. Maybe it's all of that. We went 9-10 in a brutal stretch. We picked up half a game since beginning of last week. Dropped 1.5 since the end of the Cubs series. Could've been better. Could've been worse. I think the toll on the bullpen is a legit worry. Some guys are going to have to step here, especially if Miller is toast. We have to get some length from our starters or win some games 12-5 or something in these next 17 games, I would think. DL Hall makes a big difference if he's back. Gasser too. We're also in this weird in between phase where we have to play to win in order to secure the division (plus bye, because division without bye isn't all that meaningful seeing as we've done that multiple times over the past couple years), but we also have to think about October. I don't know. This stretch was just a grind, and we came out okay. There's still work to be done. But hard to gripe too much. On today's game, here's one thing. I've watched a lot of baseball in my life, and I usually have a pretty good sense of what's going on. I can tell if a pitch is a ball before it gets to homeplate. When a ball comes off the bat, I can usually tell if it's a hit or not (even ground balls up the middle, which has been an adjustment). Close plays at first. Tag plays. All the same. I'm not always right, but I have a sense. Check swings, I have ZERO idea what's happening. Flip a coin. They are the black box of baseball. So many routine judgement calls get made in the course of a game, and it all feels totally arbitrary. I don't think there's a way to fix that. Maybe it's just uncertainty we have to live with. I can get behind that. Living with uncertainty is important. But I don't blame Murphy for getting upset today. You figure you get one of the two coin flips in the Realmuto AB. Didn't happen. Them's the brakes. Deep breaths, day off, let's roll up at least 12 more wins before the month's out.

Tucker played the bounce terribly as well.

Totally get this perspective, but I care not at all about HFA in the LCS and WS, mostly because those three games in the middle, right in a row, feel better to me than the two plus two. And if it goes 6, there's so much pressure on the home team. Feels like a trivial difference. Not like I would be mad at being the 1, but I would certainly prioritize rest/rhythm rather than go all out for it, assuming the bye is clinched. Maybe I'd feel differently in 2-2-1-1-1 sports like the NBA and NHL, but it's still not something I'd get worked up about. Though more home games are nicer for the cash flow, so that's something (and none of this applies to the shorter postseason rounds). Maybe someone has the numbers, but I feel like HFA seems least important to me in baseball. And I generally think it's overrated in all major sports, save for European soccer, where having to fly all the way to Kazakhstan or go to Marseille where the fans camp outside the team hotel and keep you awake all night feels like a much bigger deal.

Extra helpful that Counsell went to Palencia, who has struggled lately. That's a nice week for us. I know we only need 1 against the Phils to get the breaker. That would be good. But let's go ahead and win the series. And, hey! Off day Tuesday!

We'll see how this Cubs game shakes out, but to have a week where you gain ground while facing the best team in the AL while your biggest competition faces the worst team in baseball is fine to good. That's the good news. The bad news is Woody looked very hittable, and we ran the bases like Little Leaguers, except maybe worse. The other good news is that the Phillies have had to win two close games vs. the Braves, and now they play Sunday night baseball before traveling to Milwaukee for an afternoon game, and we rested all our best relievers. I don't know what any of that really means in the aggregate, but we'll be at least 5 (.499999) up on September 1. I will take that many times out of many times.

Gameday is not having nice things to say about the ump so far...though maybe that's the most redundant thing it's possible to say in a game thread (with the possible exception of declaring the game a loss).