I don't really know what to make of these four games. Probably nothing. I think the hard part is, a lot of us felt some serious "uh-ohs" looking at the Opening Day roster and seeing how it had been impacted by injuries and how many question marks there were in the lineup. As Brewers fans, we're probably conditioned to expect the other the shoe to drop more than most franchises, and the easiest thing in the world is to see your worst fears realized completely in a small sample and then extrapolate that out to forever.
We're obviously going to play better. But this roster construction really does seem troubling. They let Adames go and signed no one, basically counting on Yelich to be MVP Yelich and Hoskins to have a bounce-back year, not to mention Chourio taking a step forward after the league starts to adjust to him a bit more. Mark Canha is not the answer, but I was puzzled by trading him for cash. His bat's useful! Especially against lefties (which we can't hit). Then there's letting Rea go and signing your one pitching FA late in camp, when you know you're going to be very careful with Woodruff. Maybe it's easy to criticize all that in hindsight, but I do think there are some avoidable errors in there that have compounded the bad injury luck.
Here's my takeaway: I don't see a reason to panic. Panic after four games is silly. But there are some warning signs here that you'd be silly not to notice, especially when nobody is hitting and even our good bullpen pitchers are really struggling. We can't throw strikes. We can't stop giving up hard contact. Other than the opener (where Freddy pitched like a pretty good, B, maybe B- outing), every defensive half-inning has been an adventure. It's not just that the pitching is thin. It's that nobody has been able to look like an above-average big-league pitcher outside of your staff "ace," who's really more like a number 2 or number 3 starter (not a Freddy criticism, that's just who he realistically is). When you pair that with an offense that scored nine runs in a game they were only briefly in (largely thanks to some very bad Yankees defense) and six runs in the other three games (aided greatly by Devin walking dudes), ouch. You get a very lopsided 0-4 and a lot of folks asking some legitimate questions about what realistic expectations are for this roster.
On the other hand, maybe we just faced a world-beating offense and a million left-handed pitchers and are better than the rest of the NL Central. Ask me again in two weeks.