Those mid-major conference tourneys are what makes March Madness great though…and I’m sure it shoots viewership through the roof. Considering most of those mid-majors are destined to get absolutely rocked in the first round or at best make the round of 32…why not make some excitement getting into the tourney?
I don’t think there is a problem with a team having a losing conference record, but sometimes teams really get propped up because their schedule is crazy tough.
There is no merit to thinking sub .500 team shouldn’t make the tourney. Iowa state has beat Kansas, Kansas State, Baylor, TCU twice, and Texas. Going to be pretty darn hard to get manage a .500 record when you play Top 10 teams for 8 of those games.
Sure, Iowa State is probably the most extreme example. But I’d take a middling Power 5 team over some second place team from the horizon league or similar. We already waste a spot every year on some garbage Horizon League champion…no need to make it more.