I dont think anyone here is saying that EVERY time someone is in a contract year they will somehow magically perform better because of it. Im not sure if you think that is what I am arguing. What originally started this is that you wrote "this contract year silliness needs to stop". I do not agree. Some players/people are going to play harder and prepare better when they know that a several million dollar, guaranteed contract is on the line. Now, once that large, guaranteed contract is signed maybe one does not feel as inclined to take extra batting pratice, work out as hard, dive for that ball, etc. Because not many of us personally know many of these players, at times, bringing up a possible "contract year" result, such as I did with Silva, should be brought up.