Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic

Lathund

Verified Member
  • Posts

    1,909
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Lathund last won the day on March 9 2024

Lathund had the most liked content!

Recent Profile Visitors

3,848 profile views

Lathund's Achievements

First Round Pick

First Round Pick (4/14)

  • General Manager
  • NICE
  • Aw Shucks
  • Am I Okay?
  • Fortnighter

Recent Badges

668

Reputation

  1. Luke Adams is the most MLB-ready 1B (And occasional 3B) prospect the Brewers have, and he's a righty. His issue has been staying healthy, but he has produced at every level. Not sure he can have all that much success being quite as passive as he is, but deserves a chance to prove that he can. Or that he can change.
  2. I wouldn't make huge changes this offseason. I'd stick with Contreras for the rest of his contract. Extension if they can agree to something that makes sense, otherwise QO. QO for Bauers would depend on how much they like Adams/Fischer/Burke (And to a lesser extent Black and Wilken). If he accepts, I'm trading Vaughn. I have no idea what Woodys market is. If he's up for a cheap deal with incentives for IP, I'm all for it. Regardless of whether Made signs an extension and gets promoted early or not, I'm keeping both Ortiz and Hamilton. Both have options, and we saw with the Bae/Ornelas situation that depth is good to have. Lots of talk about trading Mitchell or Frelick, I don't see any reason to. Plenty of playing time to go around for Chourio/Mitchell/Frelick/Lara/(Bauers). Depth is good, if some prospect OF (Adamczewski?) is too good to not promote, then you can consider a trade. All four have options remaining too should it come to that. Backup C (Or primary if Contreras is traded, which I expect he won't be) is the last one then. Quero is out of options, so it's either waivers, trade, or opening day roster. If he can catch, he's the OD backup. If he can't, he's gone. Naylor has an option, so he'll be in AAA if Quero is on the roster, opening day backup otherwise. I don't know how good Wood and Miller are defensively (I *think* Wood is better?), but could be solid backups if they are decent. If they don't believe in them or in Quero's catching, signing a defensive specialist wouldn't be a bad move. Let Contreras DH against some tough lefties, keep him off his feet a bit more while getting some elite defense in there. Knees aren't immune to the rigors of catching, no matter how motivated you are to play every day. Onto pitching. Miz, Henderson, Gasser seem a clear 1-3. Priester if healthy, and Harrison if he's back to himself (I think he will be). Woodruff if the above deal allows for it too. Drohan, Crow, Sproat are solid back of the rotation backup 40-man options. Ashby if they're willing to entertain the idea. Gordon and Stallings are depth. Patrick too, but I think they don't view him as a starter. Hardin and Letson in AAA. A ton of depth, even if much is untested. If no Woody, I wouldn't mind some veteran signing though to get us through the regular season. Bullpen will have some of the guys squeezed out of the rotation, along with the returning A bullpen, as well as some possible relief prospects (Wagoner for one). Zerpa and Fitzpatrick returning at some point too, though obviously not opening day. Megill is a possible trade candidate. Could go either way on that. Trading him and signing the best available reliever for the money saved would net a prospect or two for a small downgrade. But I also don't think the return is huge, and financially there is no great pressing need so perhaps just ride it out. If no QO for Bauers, and no other big spending, then this could even be a year to spend some money on 1-year deals in the bullpen. There's no real pressure or need to make any big moves. The team is also young enough and with a good enough farm that they're also not forced to trade any expiring contracts if they don't want to. I would say though that I'd be surprised if all three "expensive" expiring contracts (Vaughn, Contreras, Megill) are on the roster in 2027, but it's certainly doable should they choose to keep them all. But as I think I say every year in these posts, the team will do at least one move that noone predicted. Like last year, trading/releasing every player who played 3B for the Brewers in 2025.
  3. I'm a big fan of Megill, and would be happy to keep him. But to counter your argument; Adding a veteran writer/director like Cameron Crowe to the roster adds something we don't currently have. In fact, no other team in baseball does either. How do you prepare for that as an opponent? It's completely uncharted ground. Yet another case of the Brewers finding a new edge.
  4. Brewers are better this year than last. They're healthier. And winning the NLDS in 4 instead of 5 means having everyone rested, and able to line up the pitching exactly the way they want. Now is that enough to win the series? Who knows. I'll still have the Dodgers as favorites. But it won't be as one-sided as last year, and the chances of winning are IMO quite clearly better.
  5. Has he, though? He has a 100 wRC+ with the Cardinals in AA, exactly average for the league. OBP down 74 points and SLG down 279 (!) points compared to what he did in Biloxi. Now I'm not going to try to use either of these small samples (119 PA with Brewers AA, 141 PA with the Cardinals) to make any kind of point about his future (Or the trade overall), just pointing out that I don't think it's correct to say he's been on an absolute tear since the trade.
  6. This is Chourio's age 22 season. When PCA finished his age 22 season, his was .228/.282/.370 (81 wRC+) for his career. Still 2.4 fWAR due to defense. Point being that a lot can happen in two years. Right now it's PCA, but I also don't buy that this hot streak is who he is as a hitter. And I also think there's more to come from Jackson.
  7. I think that with his stuff, even marginally better command makes him a viable MLB player. The harder part to figure out might be the inconsistency, or how one mistake seemingly becomes a second, and a third. I think the best way to use him in AAA would still be to keep him reasonably stretched out, but coming in as a reliever, to see how he handles that routine.
  8. It's hard to sell at the deadline for a contending team. The timing of the Hader trade didn't exactly play out very well, Or you might not get the opportunity to trade them due to injuries (to them, or other pitchers on the roster), or due to being in a tight division race and so on. So I feel like you have to decide in the offseason how set you are on trading them, how you'd feel if you didn't manage to. Any player you feel like you have to trade, do it in the offseason. Ones where you'd like to trade them, but would be OK either way, you could leave until midseason. For a non-contending team, it's not as clear cut.
  9. After getting over the initial shock, my thoughts are mostly that I'm OK with including Ragsdale. I'm not buying that he's suddenly a power hitter, and I think the accompanying strikeout rate is more likely to stick than the power is. Still, he's a good prospect, but with Lara, Chourio and Mitchell already here, and Payne/Adamczewski in the system, it's the kind of good prospect that I get you have to include in trades. Not a fan of including Frias at all though. He is so far away from the majors that there is a lot of risk with him, but my philosophy is generally that the players with the big-time tools, you keep. It's the only way you can get your homegrown superstars. So I'd have prefered someone else in there, this feels like an overpay. At the same time though I can see the logic. We have other outfielders, and including Frias won't hurt us for several more years even if he does make it big (and he might never). Im glad it wasn't Josh Knoth; I feel it's vital that we keep our best pitching prospects around. So I'm in the camp of "I don't like it, but it's not the disaster I initially thought it was".
  10. Pitched full reliever workloads (between 62 and 69 appearances eahc year) from 2021-2024, made 31 starts (33 appearances total) last year. Getting hit with that line drive seems like the only absence he's had in the last 6 years. Hardly what I'd call injury prone. Every pitcher is an injury waiting to happen, but he doesn't strike me as any more injury prone than normal.
  11. The decline on both sides of the ball in the last couple of seasons is why I'm perfectly fine just letting the contract run out after next season, and only re-sign in free agency if a reasonable short-term deal can be agreed to. So in other words, most likely not re-signing. We obviously don't know if this is the start of his decline, or something temporary, but I'd rather not risk signing a catcher for big money into his mid 30s with this trend.
  12. I couldn't tell you about Brewers.tv, but for someone based outside the US with mlb.tv, the game is unavailable. And Peacock is US only, so couldn't pay to watch the game even if I wanted to.
  13. The way I look at it, in the postseason Brewers could get far by improving relief pitching. The starting pitching is good, and shorter starts are less of an issue when your A bullpen can pitch basically every game. With Skubal gone, there also aren't really any starters who are a clear upgrade. And starters, especially with control remaining, are expensive. Adrian Morejon (If the Padres are selling) and Luke Weaver would be ideal IMO. There are other names out there, but those would be among the best relievers who might be available. Having a lead in the 5th and getting to close it out with Morejon, Weaver, Uribe, Megill sounds like a good plan to me. A rental reliever, even a very good one, won't require a true top prospect. Weaver has another year of control, but is paid near market rate so doesn't add a ton of value or cost. Adding another starter to help get the team to the postseason could also be a good idea, but I wouldn't shop at the very top of the market for that. A Freddy reunion if the price is right perhaps.
  14. Obviously not an exact science, and would vary a lot between what source you go on. And what really matters is how the teams view these guys; presumably they liked these guys better than the consensus, and the guys in the alternative packages less. The Athletic (Keith Law): Hope 26th, Ryan 41st. He has Luis Peña 21st and Alexander Frias 69th. So those two + a better third piece. Pipeline: Hope 25th, Ryan 68th, Brady Smith 17th in Dodgers sytem. Brewers: Peña 18th, Lara 64th. Blake Burke is 17th, Ethan Dorchies is the closest pitcher at 19th. Fangraphs: Ryan 22nd, Hope 57th, Brady Smith 23rd in system with 40+ FV. Luis Peña is 26th, with Frias 43rd and Brady Ebel 63rd. Brewers lowest 40+ are Strosnider and Trey Ebel. 40+ Pitchers are Dubanewicz, Thompson, Wichrowski. Can't be bothered to check more sources at this time, but roughly speaking it would be Peña, whoever you think the Brewers 3rd best prospect is (Lara, Frias), and whoever you have as the Brewers 4th best pitching prospect after Hardin/Letson/Knoth.
×
×
  • Create New...