BrewerFan
Verified Member-
Posts
5,632 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
10
BrewerFan last won the day on November 11
BrewerFan had the most liked content!
Recent Profile Visitors
7,869 profile views
BrewerFan's Achievements
-
The Antigua feel like they're choking me and are too tight... and then if I move up a size, they're better there, but then they look like what a young girl who is trying to hide a pregnancy would be wearing. I got a couple and I'm just going to have them taken in a little bit. Also, just curious, and I'll preface this by saying it's the best year to do this. But... it kinda feels like we're doing too much. The Murp "tour" and what-not, it's disconcerting.
-
I don't think they'll even try and re-sign Romero. 3/30 is likely what it'll cost and I don't think we'll pay it. I also think Senzatela is a better choice as I believe he'll sign for much cheaper. Upper 90s fastball, he's got a starters mix and he's a heavy GB pitcher. I'd also take May back if it would have been reasonable. He's got the same things going for him. Big arm, velo, he USED to be a big GB pitcher. At 1/8M he was worth it. AT 20M+ which... he was always going to get, obviously not. Clay Holmes would be far more interesting at this point, but I suspect hell also cost 15M AAV and get 3 years. So... we'll just have to keep getting by with our sad, little pitching development!
-
You don't think they were winning that WS without JoJo or May? They gave up an 18-year-old with massive power and a top 100 prospect and Ragsdale... who I was actually fine with. But just winning doesn't mean every trade was worth it. Made for Skubal... we'd almost certainly have won it. I wouldn't have defended it. But, I am not as annoyed by the trade obviously because... winning it IS objectively cool, but I don't agree with the logic.
-
I think Adams, Wagoner, Jett Wiliams was obvious. I think Wood was a logical addition. I would have gone with Witchrowski over Kuehner, but either way. And O'Rae has played VERY well. He had a down year in '25 IIRC, injuries, but... he's a pretty talented and versatile utility player. I don't think any of these are surprising. And it's not like you have to keep all these players all year and can't sign anyone. You can also remove Stallings for example. Not a big deal to be at 40 going into the lockout.
-
More "talented?" What's this even mean? Just pure talent? Eric Bitonti is probably more talented. I'd guess he's #5 on the list of internal options to take over 1B and he's still a couple years away. Fischer is probably more "talented," if we're being literal. Do you mean better or just purely talented? You could argue it I suppose. Saying "C'mon man," like it's some outrageous claim... tells me you're inserting "better today," for "talented."
-
I suspect they also thought he'd be worth considerably more than 22M in 2020, 2021, 2022. He'd just put up 14.5 WAR, .327/.415/.631 and a 1.045 OPS, and they gave him 7 years and 188.5M in new money... I do not think they were expecting him to be a star in 2027, but... I'd imagine they were expecting him to be one for several more years and even by 2027, a solid hitter.... and I actually DO think they thought he'd be worth 26M(or the 22 they were paying and the deferred money). Again, I don't think anyone is talking about "expected statistics." They're talking about all the metrics that point to... what type of hitter you were. Not just Steamer. Hard hit, chase, bat speed... there's not much to argue for regression....
-
There's been some inflation, but... it's also a matter of a top 3 prospect who played in the OF vs a Switch Hitting SS who is the consensus #1. I just think he's more valuable at this point than Chourio was. I'd gladly take that 9/140. I'd love to see a TO in there as well. That's not really giving up much for the player. 9 years, the Brewers would very likely control him for 7 years. I don't even know if the Brewers would move him straight from AA to 3rd Base next year anyway. He'd very possibly start the year in the minors... Funny though, I remember a lot of pushback to the Chourio signing. Lot of risk, etc... etc... I just love what the Brewers are doing. You take up what they may end up giving Made, Pratt, Lara, Chourio, Ashby... you don't need a 100% hit rate, you can deal with a miss and done right, I think you end up coming out ahead. I've been a big advocate of this for a while... of course I also thought the Braves had perfected that and that hasn't worked out quite as good as many thought it would.
- 18 replies
-
- jesus made
- joey ortiz
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
I'm not really following the point you're trying to make here. You acknowledge that some of Made's production came from home runs, while the rest could reflect either quality contact or BABIP luck. But isn't that true of virtually every hitter? Made had a .294 BABIP on the season, and his walk and strikeout rates remained strong even during his slumps. What specifically about his performance leads you to believe there's something concerning here?
- 18 replies
-
- 1
-
-
- jesus made
- joey ortiz
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
Pretty unpopular opinion, but... yeah, I do. It's not like Greg mismanaged games, we got just incredibly bad luck or sometimes weren't the best team. If Hader doesn't give up a couple big hits to Soto and Freeman we're advancing, if the hard hit balls vs the Dbacks were normalized, we advance that year. Williams gave up a 3R HR to Alanso... though, that might have been Murphy. Anyway, it just kinda speaks to the variance in the post-season. But... maybe. I know we won a World Series with the guy who stuck around... and Chicago hasn't. So I can talk myself into that version as well!
-
I actually don't think he is. Chase rate, hard hit rate, none of his performance this year suggests it was a fluke year. I'm... perfectly fine with the Brewers not matching this, glad we'll get an additional 1st rd pick... that's great. But I also don't think Bauers is a particularly big regression risk. I'm more worried about Contreras over the next 4-5 years and it sounds like we're much more interested in re-signing him, likely for more money per year.
-
Do you mean 20-80?
-
I'm looking and he's been very good vs RHHers the last couple of years. He was also used for more than 3 outs regularly, even in the playoffs. Just vs RHHing 2025- .220 /.327 /.315 OPS of .642 2026 -.228/ .315 /.346 OPS of .661 This is why he's going to be priced out of Milwaukee anyway. He's just been a very good reliever(worse vs lefties this than righties, so certainly not exclusively a loogy).
-
I was absolutely NOT saying the Brewers should give May that type of money! I was saying I'd like to bring him back because I am of the belief that he's got really good stuff, the Brewers could get him back to being more of that Groundball pitcher. Basically it's as surface level as he's got that good velo that I love AND a history of really good GB rates that makes me think... there's something to work with at his age. Definitely not giving him 34M and beyond that, he left immediately, took no part in the parade. I suspect he believes he should have been a larger part of the team. If we're going to pay closer to market value for one of the FA pitchers, I'd go with Senzatela for the same reasons as May. Very good GB rate, good velo, I think his stuff would continue to play up away from Coors. I'd also be thrilled to get back Romero for 2/12, but he's not signing at that price. I love the Starting pitching depth. I've heard people say(via podcasts and the like) the Brewers really like Hardin and believe his stuff will really continue to play up... and we'll have 2-3 MLB caliber starters in AAA.
-
Yeah, there were a couple times I remember hoping he'd come back, but I didn't realize just how close or how interested the Brewers were, so... I looked it up. I'm stealing this from ChatGTP... but it has links; 1. November–December 1995: Milwaukee seriously tried to re-sign him After Toronto declined his option, Molitor visited Milwaukee and met with Sal Bando and Bud Selig. The Brewers offered him two years and $4 million, plus another $1 million for five years of front-office work after retirement. Molitor initially favored returning to Milwaukee, according to a detailed Shepherd Express reconstruction of contemporary reporting. He ultimately chose Minnesota, partly because it was home and partly because he wasn't sure returning to Milwaukee would recreate what he'd enjoyed before leaving. This article editorializes it quite a bit, but... touches on the facts; https://shepherdexpress.com/sports/brew-crew-confidential/paul-molitor-goes-home-brewers-miss-ignitor-part-ii/?utm_source=chatgpt.com 2. After the 1998 season: Milwaukee offered him a job This is the clearest answer to your coaching question. SABR's biography states that Molitor turned down an opportunity to join the Brewers' front office or field staff after retiring. He wanted to take his first year away from playing to enjoy life before committing to another baseball job. 3. August 1999: Molitor was rumored as a managerial candidate This one is documented in contemporary national reporting. When Milwaukee dismissed Phil Garner and GM Sal Bando on August 12, 1999, speculation immediately centered on whether Paul Molitor or Robin Yount might return to fill one of the vacancies. In an Associated Press report published by The Washington Post, Brewers president Wendy Selig-Prieb was asked about both former players. She described the rumors as premature because the organization hadn't begun its formal search. That establishes a genuine managerial rumor, but I haven't found evidence Milwaukee formally interviewed or offered Molitor the job. The Washington Post 4. November 2001: His name surfaced again for manager or hitting coach This may be the specific rumor you're remembering. A November 2001 OnMilwaukee column suggested that Molitor could return as Milwaukee's hitting coach or even manager. The context was unusual: MLB was discussing eliminating two franchises, with Minnesota potentially among them. Molitor was coaching for the Twins, and there was speculation he could become available if that organization disappeared. The columnist explicitly advocated bringing him to Milwaukee. It was speculation, not a documented offer. I could certainly see that fitting what you're talking about. I remember a lot of speculation about him becoming a hitting coach and then a manager among fans, but... him coming back and getting 3,000 hits in Milwaukee, PLUS... we weren't as bad those years as I would have thought going off memory. We were better than the Twins and then 80-82 one year and just a couple games worse another year, so it was a chance to really help heal the franchise there... but, it wasn't to be.
-
No, I think people are looking at the additional money, Bauers reports that he'll turn down the QO(which would leave the Brewers with considerably more money to work with... barring the Brewers giving him ~2/40 or something) and using that as their rationale. I said I'd like May back... knowing full well he won't be as even with his performance he'll likely cost 2/34... but if we're just saying what we'd like, I'd like to have not traded for him and then signed him because I think the Brewers could do wonders with him. But, I love the SPing. Harrison was an ace most of the year, he wore down. I think there's reason to expect him to throw better in his 2nd year. Sproat has a ton of upside. I don't actually expect Burnes, but I think you can at least look at their terrible seasons and their stuff and you knew Burnes was still likely to be a good pitcher and I feel the same way about Sproat. Gasser... probably pitched a little over his head in the post-season, but he was also coming back from TJ. Drohan was solid, Priester. Hardin could easily be ready next year, Letson could be ready for the team later i the year. He has a big upside. Rather than just sign a pitcher to sign a pitcher, I'd like to see some more long term extensions. The one we all want is obvious, but beyond that... there are a couple depending on what they'd take. Turang likely gone(though... I'd certainly rather invest there than Catcher given Contreras age and decline, despite his legendary WS which we'll never forget). Either way, we're good. We have trade chips and young arms and arms who got experiance. I don't think we need to make a single move, anything we do is just adding to an already really good team that on paper, should be better next year.

