I don't know. There is very little difference between Thames and Smoak. Smoak is a switch hitter, but he's so much better as a lefty that the SH thing isn't really an advantage with him. He's not a good righty hitter. We seem to be fueled by a constant desire for change and this search for a "professional" hitter, whatever that is, we apparently do not have any. Ops+: Thames 102 Smoke 127 Smoak also strikes out less, walks more = professional hitter. Career ops+ (because that is what really matters) Thames 108 Smoke 106 Also, Smoak's average is down to .224 now, similar to his .233 career average. I would imagine that ops+ will come back to career average as well. I totally get the idea of trying to improve at the 1B position. I just don't think Smoak is an improvement, though, and the numbers bear that out. I think this would be a change simply to make a change.