Ok, Chis I understand that. I guess I think the odds of needing the 3rd Catcher are low(I'm sure Billy Hall can do everything!). Just in that spot i know you are rolling the dice a bit, but it is a chance to win too. If we fear ever hitting for Moeller, maybe we need to add a utility guy that could catch in a pinch, or at least anotehr postion player for another bat. Maybe the call up of Vinny would solve this. I'm sure the odds of needing a third catcher are low. And chances are really good that if Miller comes into the game he doesn't get hurt. But, if he does, that position is so specialized and so important that having to throw out a non-catcher is really, really scary. It's probably scarier to Yost, who's a catcher himself and as manager has to at least keep those sort of emergancy situations in mind. Yost was probably thinking something he didn't need to roll the dice because he had other things going for him even if Moeller failed in that spot: 1) If Moeller doesn't get it done, there is still a decent chance Cirillo will. 2) If they don't score at all in the 8th, he's bringing Turnbow in. They aren't gonna get any runs, which means they have the top of the order in the 9th in a tie game. If Yost is thinking like that, combine what was said about not losing a backup catcher, and its not a bad choice. I don't think the decision to leave Moeller in is a no-brainer. And, you're right, if Miller gets in for a few innings, it's probably not the end of the world. I think Yost handled it correctly, but I wouldn't have complained if he went the direction you suggested.