Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic

SeaBass

Verified Member
  • Posts

    3,443
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

 Content Type 

Profiles

Forums

Blogs

Events

Milwaukee Brewers News, Rumors & Analysis

2026 Milwaukee Brewers Top Prospect Rankings

Milwaukee Brewers Videos

2022 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Milwaukee Brewers Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Milwaukee Brewers Fan Guides & Resources

2023 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2024 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Milwaukee Brewers Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by SeaBass

  1. Milwaukee's sales tax rate is right in line and in many cases is lower than most other cities of similar size/population in the US. Nothing to see here.
  2. I think this was more a failure of the Selig family mindset more than an actual inability to be able to compete. The Seligs looked at the market disadvantage and gave up rather than try to find alternate ways to compete. They cried poor and then lived up to the restrictions they put on themselves. There wasn't a lot of investment in building actual success, they just went through the motions while adhering to traditional baseball talent acquisition from a poor team's perspective. Once Mark A arrived there was a near immediate turn around.
  3. The teams have never all had the same money to spend and yet players have been paid what they're worth. So I don't agree. Any team can sign Shohei Ohtani to the contract he signed with the Dodgers and they'd be able to pay it. It's just that most other teams declined to do it or Ohtani really preferred to get a deal done specifically with the Dodgers. A salary cap is not required for teams to sign players they want to sign.
  4. I think at times just putting a sentence out in public makes a person feel like they're making a difference. Are they really though or is it just a self-fulfilling feel good vibe that they've said what they think and people have to read it now. But what has it really accomplished? Not much. This is a pretty niche message board floating in the vast ocean of the internet. Aura farming doesn't really interest me that much, not that I want to reduce people's feelings about an important issue to that but really that's kind of what it is and it doesn't really serve a cause other than to feel better about one's self about having the "correct opinion" in comparison to other strangers on the internet. I know how I feel about it and I suppose the way that I "do something about it" is by using my vote to support leadership that will enact the changes I feel are for the greater good. I don't need to get into arguments with other sports fans that this certain thing needs to be acknowledged or I can't enjoy sports. So, I have feelings about it, I have beliefs that I feel are at the core of what I envision supports human rights but I don't think that being asked to avoid the topic on a sports message board is unreasonable. And just because that's how I feel about it that doesn't make my view correct for everyone else. In the end I'm back at square one, making a difference in the only way I truly can.
  5. I don't have much reason to doubt this but no team building method is infallible. Good teams go through cycles of greater success and lesser success.
  6. I'm pretty dead set against a cap but the years of control on a young player become less important in a capped league. The Brewers value that control because it's literally how they are able to compete while still keeping salaries low. With a cap they'd have money to compete against all the other teams to sign them to extensions or once they hit free agency. I'm not going to pretend that having a cap is going to be an end to what the Brewers do, they'll just have to do it a little differently. I like how the Brewers are operating their team, I hope it pays off in a couple two tree more World Series appearances in the short term. But I'm not going to fall victim to the thought that what the Brewers are doing is going to work from now to the end of time. The league is already showing signs of adjusting, it's the new moneyball and that was adjusted to also. The Brewers will need to keep finding success zigging while other teams zag. My specific reasons for being against the cap is simply that I believe the players should be able to make whatever the market demands without restriction. I'm also not sold that a cap is going to be the huge boon to small market teams that everyone else does, the gap between the proposed floor and cap is still large enough to where big markets will still have a pretty hefty advantage when it comes to bidding on the best of the best free agents around the league. In essence, I'm not sure the landscape really changes that much and the Brewers will still need to grind to compete.
  7. How bold of them on November 18th. Truly withstanding the pressure.
  8. Yeah as to your last sentence, I kind of like to see them getting to the championship round, basically the Final Four of NFL. They've done that plenty of times. They have just unfortunately not gotten past it. They probably should have at least twice since 2011 but that's the pain we bear as fans. Is it enough? I'm not sure.
  9. I had spotted that error too, I'd like to think the overall records are close. Success is subjective. They've been to and won one Super Bowl in the 2000s. For some that's not enough, for others it is (while of course still wanting more). As a franchise they've been winning a lot of football games since the Favre era. I know I've looked up their playoff success since 1993, the first year they made the playoffs under Favre and since then they've been a playoff team in 25 of those seasons through last season. They've never gone more than 2 years without a playoff appearance in that time. I think it would be difficult for many other NFL franchises to be able to claim that same level of success. I don't know that I have the stomach to only accept Super Bowl appearances as a good enough reason to support me being a satisfied fan. That does feel like spoiled fan feelings. Sorry if that bothers you. Calling it how I see it.
  10. I don't disagree with anything you're saying. Just that when it comes to the owner/labor side of baseball I just don't see the point in restricting what players make. It's not going to change any of the other economic factors of consuming baseball as entertainment. As you said earlier, it just means that more money goes into owner's pockets. That revenue will always be what it is. Unless more and more people choose not to consume. That's the danger of the squabbling the two sides do every time CBA talks come about and games are lost. That's on both parties involved.
  11. Looks to me like the Packers have been pretty good. I think GB fans are simply pretty spoiled. None of this is meant to be an argument against changing the leadership however. I'm on board with changing the HC and while I'm more forgiving when it comes to Gute I also don't have much issue with folks wanting him to be replaced either. Basically they might be able to to better and odds of doing worse is probably less than Gute backers would think.
  12. It's entertainment. Just like movies, television, books and music. Talented people in a market with high demand will get paid more. It's how the world works. Nobody is required to buy tickets or watch on tv. It's what we choose to follow. I know you know that too but I feel like a lot of people just lose sight of it. Baseball brings in billions of dollars every season. I tune in to watch the players playing the game. I want them to get as much money as a free market demands. We don't put caps on music artists or actors but everyone is so eager to put a cap on athletes for some reason. It just doesn't, and won't ever, make sense to me.
  13. The last time the Packers finished 4th in the division Mike Sherman was fired and McCarthy was hired. That team went 4-12 though. This team probably has at least 3 more wins in them and 10 wins isn't out of the question. Not sure if a 9 or 10 win season convinces Policy or the board to make a change. Instead of seeing a missed opportunity they'll convince themselves they were just a win or two away.
  14. I'm sure according to you I am because I am about as against a salary cap as it's possible to be.
  15. The Brewers were favored in the World Series.
  16. This sure is one way to announce that Jake declined the QO lol. Good for him, glad he got paid!
  17. You literally suggested voters should be replaced for not voting for Murphy. I don't know how else to interpret that. Whatever, you knew when you responded to my post that you had complained because why else would you have cared about what I said? It's ok, you are allowed to have an opinion and so am I.
  18. Here are two posts I found that seem to fit like a glove. Since you're asking. https://brewerfanatic.com/forums/topic/48748-moty-x-3-murph-did-it-again/#findComment-1812825 https://brewerfanatic.com/forums/topic/48748-moty-x-3-murph-did-it-again/#findComment-1812831
  19. Are we seriously complaining that Murph wasn't a unanimous 1st place vote getter? He ran away with the award, maybe just be happy for the guy. He also got the most 1st place votes out of all managers, including the AL ballot (Venable had 15 1st place votes) where voters couldn't vote for Murph. Murph is respected guys, it's going to be ok.
  20. These negotiations don't start until MLB gives up on their cute little salary cap side project.
  21. I think it's interesting to look back at the thoughts that were happening at the time. But I'm not looking to laugh at takes that were opposed to moves though. I think most of the time those posters have valid reasons for the way they felt and shouldn't be called out retroactively for it.
  22. The thing I think possibly held Ortiz out of the utility GG award is he doesn't play outfield. I think that's kind of valid honestly. Ortiz was basically a 2 position player, that's not that great when it comes to true utility. He played one game each at 2B and 1B this season, otherwise it was just SS, 3B.
  23. Not surprising at all yet I see so many Brewers fans on this message board that don't seem to think he's been our best player this year. Outside of possibly Miz he absolutely has been.
  24. As fans it's easy to become desensitized to how much money is paid to players every season but it absolutely would be a crazy gamble. I think most people when offered a choice between $23M or $50M are taking the $50M. It's not a foregone conclusion but I think he's very likely to decline unless there's info out there that the high number we're thinking of isn't actually going to happen.
  25. I've posted before that I would be against a big money extension for Contreras but screw it, I'm happy. Give him the bag. Google AI sees speculation in the 6/$120 to 6/$150 range. Maybe Wild Bill gives a tad of a hometown discount, I think I'd be ok with this through his age 36 season.
×
×
  • Create New...