I'm pretty dead set against a cap but the years of control on a young player become less important in a capped league. The Brewers value that control because it's literally how they are able to compete while still keeping salaries low. With a cap they'd have money to compete against all the other teams to sign them to extensions or once they hit free agency. I'm not going to pretend that having a cap is going to be an end to what the Brewers do, they'll just have to do it a little differently.
I like how the Brewers are operating their team, I hope it pays off in a couple two tree more World Series appearances in the short term. But I'm not going to fall victim to the thought that what the Brewers are doing is going to work from now to the end of time. The league is already showing signs of adjusting, it's the new moneyball and that was adjusted to also. The Brewers will need to keep finding success zigging while other teams zag.
My specific reasons for being against the cap is simply that I believe the players should be able to make whatever the market demands without restriction. I'm also not sold that a cap is going to be the huge boon to small market teams that everyone else does, the gap between the proposed floor and cap is still large enough to where big markets will still have a pretty hefty advantage when it comes to bidding on the best of the best free agents around the league. In essence, I'm not sure the landscape really changes that much and the Brewers will still need to grind to compete.