Like the title says, my 1994 Civic is looking a little tired, and I'm looking to upgrade. I've been back and forth on a few of them over the past month or so, but really don't know a whole lot about cars except for reviews here and there. My price range is up to $14,000 - preferably after taxes, title, etc., but I do have a little leeway and so a few hundred dollars wouldn't kill a deal for me. I'm looking for something that is reliable, decent gas mileage, and fairly small. I've test-driven a Scion XD and a Hyundai Elantra so far, but wasn't all that blown away by either. I've also ridden in a Ford Focus, and partially know how it is. Currently I'm looking at: Honda Civic 2005 - 33k miles @ $12,000 from a dealer Honda Civic 2005 - 28.5k miles @ $12,000 from a private party Hyundai Elantra 2007 - 15-30k miles @ $12,500 from a dealer Honda Fit 2007 - 20k miles @ $14,500 from a dealer - kind of pushing it with the price after tax and everything else Scion XD 2008 - ~20k miles @ $14,000 from a dealer. Ford Focus 2009 - Brand New @ $12,300-$12,500 from a dealer. They all seem to have their pros and cons, but I'll name a few that stick out to me: Civics - Pros: Reliability, Reliability, Reliability. Price tag. Cons: 2005 is older than the other choices, 1 year away from the 2006 redesign. Elantra - Pros: 5 year, 60k warranty. Consumer Reports and Edmunds seem to give them good scores. Cons: Don't know a lot about them - seem to be getting better as a company though. Fit - Pros: Reliability, Reliabity, Reliability. Cons: Price is kind of up there. Scion - Pros: I actually enjoy it's appearance - I know that many don't though. Seems to have good standard features. Cons: Large blindspots in the back are my main concerns. Focus - Pros: Cheap for being new. Cons: Doesn't seem to stand out in any areas, interior seemed kind of poor when I rode in one over the summer. I think I can knock off the Scion as an option, as the rear-visibility bugs me. The civics, elantra, and focus seem to be tied as my #1 choice though. Any help/suggestions would be greatly appreciated.