This is worse than Brewers’ 2022 (for which I blame the front office for not adding a bat) and Bucks-Heat 2023 (just weren’t up to it), though not as bad as Packers-49ers 2022 (give a bleep about special teams play; hey offense, do something - way to waste the best defense we’ve had in years).
I’d have zero second thoughts if the likes of Tellez, Wiemer, Winker, Monasterio, Anderson, Miller and Jahmai Jones didn’t bat in the 2023 postseason, as they were all struggling (or just not doing enough) coming in. I also don’t mind Hiura (some minor injury) and Black (service time manipulation) not getting a chance.
But I’ll always wonder what Caratini, Perkins, Mitchell and Toro would have done.
- Would Burnes have thrown better with his personal catcher behind the plate (w/Taylor in CF, Canha in RF, Frelick on the bench instead of hitting 5th)?
- Would Caratini have contributed anything as a hitter in Game 1 or batting instead of Monasterio in the 9th inning of Game 2?
- Perkins has consistently hit LHP slightly better than RHP - would he have come through instead of Frelick in the 8th inning of Game 2?
- Mitchell can impact in many ways - disruptive force on bases, CF defense, ability to run out a ground ball for a single or flare for a double, even just excitement which fuels the crowd. Was he the missing link?
- Toro ends the season with a 41-game on-base streak. He just knows how to come through in the second half of 2023, unlike some other guy who got paid $8m this year. Sure, his fielding is mediocre, but the effort is 100%. Switch-hit bat who can do more than Miller, Monasterio, Turang, Winker…
Am I an idiot for imagining that guys like Caratini, Perkins, Mitchell and/or Toro would have made a difference? Alas…something to ponder for as long as God lets me.