Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic

Brewcrew82

Verified Member
  • Posts

    10,714
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    125

Brewcrew82 last won the day on October 9 2024

Brewcrew82 had the most liked content!

Recent Profile Visitors

15,496 profile views

Brewcrew82's Achievements

Biloxi Shuckers

Biloxi Shuckers (8/14)

  • Now Let's Talk About This Rare
  • Loudmouth Rare
  • You Really, Really Like Me Rare
  • Squatter
  • Mom's Basement

Recent Badges

6.5k

Reputation

  1. Yeah, also Vaughn's BABIP this year was 50 points more than his previous career high at .355. For comparison, that was greater than Jackson Chourio's .348 BABIP... Do we really think that holds up, especially as he gets more exposure to the tough righties the Brewers largely shielded him from this year? Steamer has Vaughn projected for a 108 wRC+ this year. That is a fair expectation in my view.
  2. Funny enough the Bauers signing effectively signals the end of Tristan Casas in Boston. If the Brewers do keep Vaughn, Casas would make a lot of sense for them as a left-handed platoon option to replace Bauers.
  3. These are all good points, but I wouldn't leave out that Vaughn's metrics declined last year. I also don't think the Brewers were happy with their investment in Hoskins in hindsight. Plus they didn't have a Luke Adams, for instance, mashing in AAA back then.
  4. Disagree. For a small market franchise it does. They pretty much never pay relievers that amount, trading them before they get that expensive. Vaughn's fWAR is projected to be about the same as Trevor Megill, who they're reportedly open to trading. I can see them going with Vaughn as there is a legitimate argument that the hammate sapped his power, but again. I'm not totally convinced for the aforementioned reasons.
  5. You said there were no pre-2026 indications of Bauers’ breakout when there definitely were. Between Bauers breaking out from the left side and Vaughn from the right side, a lot was pointing towards the Brewers having some of the best 1B production in baseball this year. Even if not quite to the extent that ended up occurring where they got literally the best production. Now you’re just getting Vaughn from the right side with the metrics indicating a clear overperformance this past season and Steamer and ZiPS projecting worse production than Luke Adams who would make $9M less. Like I said, maybe they believe in Vaughn recovering from his hammate, but I’m not convinced at $10 million after how they handled him this year.
  6. This is not true. There were definitely indications that a breakout was coming for Bauers, particularly once he got off the IL in the second half of 2025. Jack and Spencer on the Brewer Fanatic Podcast were all over it.
  7. No, I frankly don’t have the same regression concerns this year for someone who had the metrics of one of the best hitters in baseball. Some regression? Maybe. The same as Vaughn? No way.
  8. Because Jake Bauers had the metrics of one of the best hitters in baseball this year. Teams pay based on future production not on past production, Which is why metrics and projections are especially relevant.
  9. I think you need to be careful when citing his line last year. He significantly overperformed his underlying metrics. If he regresses to that and becomes an 105 wRC+ hitter instead of a 130 or 140 wRC+ hitter Bauers was, you’re looking at a decline in your 1B WAR from the 5 WAR the Brewers got this year to closer to replacement level. Maybe the hammate heals more and he’ll be fine, but there’s certainly reason for skepticism.
  10. Some sure. But also there were several situations throughout the postseason that seemingly called for Vaughn and they didn’t use him. Now they’re going to turn around and pay him almost $10 million to be the full-time 1B, including against RHP, with the cheap options they have available to them in the minors? I’m just not convinced.
  11. Are we really sure the Brewers are going to pay Vaughn almost $10 million to be the primary first baseman? After the hesitancy with which they opted to deploy him (especially vs. certain pitchers) throughout this season and into the postseason? When Luke Adams is projected to outperform him by Steamer and ZiPS.... I'm not convinced.
  12. Count me as not convinced Vaughn will be the primary first baseman.
  13. Good for him. He won't have to worry about health insurance ever again. Look forward to seeing him at the championship reunions. And another draft pick for the Brewers!
  14. In terms of an extension, there has definitely been significant inflation since Chourio agreed to his 8 year, $82 million deal three winters ago. I think the Brewers are going to have to get very close to Konnor Griffin for Made and his representatives to bite. Which ended up 9 years $140 million. They are flush with cash in the aftermath of the World Series run, so my expectation is for it to get done unless Made is dead set on getting to FA 6 years down the line (or whatever is otherwise dictated by the new CBA).
  15. I think the main separator of Chourio and Made at this stage is power actualization. Chourio's power (+speed) combo was historic for a prospect his age. Only the 5th teenager ever with a 20-40 season, alongside the likes of Acuna and Andruw Jones. While he arguably has Chourio matched from a raw power perspective (per EVs), Made still has much to work on when it comes to elevating the ball. He may have some more difficulties translating his production when he finds MLB pitchers throwing him consistent strikes if he can't elevate more. Despite Made's raw stolen base totals, I would also probably take Chourio in terms of speed and athleticism. That being said, I do think their upsides are similar when you account for Made's approach/contact ability and switch-hitting. They're just going to go about it in different ways, with one being more aggressive and the other being patient and more contact-oriented.
×
×
  • Create New...