Villar has had one very good year. I'd say great but the mental errors were racked up at a historic rate. He isn't guy with five plus years of good/very good hitting. I know CC is trying to get him going, but Sogar has to play somewhere for the time being. Why can't Sogar be this year's version of Villar or Guerra? His 'one good year' was last year, and that was the only year he played full time. I'm not thrilled with his production, but this year we need to find out if he can really put things together and be a consistently productive player. He has too much talent to discard it to easily. Sogard looks great in limited action, but at 5 years older than Villar, he doesn't likely have a long future ahead of him.