When you factor in the defense, it's hard to imagine how many games he's won for us the last couple of years. Having said that........I don't know if regression is the right word, but at the plate he DOES often leave you wishing for more. Sometimes his mindset at the plate in certain situations leaves me wanting. Like tonite. I don't remember the inning but it was still 7-2 or 7-3 & he was at the plate with no one on base and one out & chose to swing at a 3-1 pitch. Some might not agree, but if you're looking to come back in a game like this you need for the opposing pitcher to suck somewhat; to open the door. And Gilbert's command WAS off kilter tonite. For my money you take there. Instead it's a broken-bat groundout & Chourio follows with a base hit. Not a smart AB.
It's not a bad debate re dealing him if for no other reason than there's talent throughout the organization on the INF. The return would have to be bulky, though.