I enjoyed the P50 as well, but it was the unfulfileld promise of free beer and nachos that brought me to the site. I am proposing that Toby, Brian, Patrick, Jim, or whoever else get together and find 15-20 "regular" posters to compile the power 50 together in a sort of AP voting style. You could probably get by with choosing 40 minor league players per person, with a 1st place vote netting someone 40 points, 2nd place vote 39, etc etc. One person "chairs" the list and provides comments, adds up the totals and sends them along to Brian. It could lead to more discussion and if we can avoid a playoff at all costs, lots of "watercooler debates"