I'm a little surprised that there seem to be a fair number of people, here and elsewhere, with a fairly strong opinion on Weeks as the bench coach, both positive and negative. Beyond what he did as a player I don't feel like there is much information out there to give any indication of how he will fare as a coach. I don't know that his high on base percentage or struggles defensively say anything about how he will do as a coach. His successes and failures, like most players, seem more likely to be due to his physical abilities rather than lack of understanding of how to play the game. I wasn't worried when Counsell was hired as the manager that he was going to ruin Ryan Braun by forcing him into a using a goofy batting stance and I wouldn't be worried Weeks is going to turn Turang into a butcher defensively. Whether he'll be good as a coach or not, I have no idea.
Murphy has been the right hand man of one of the best managers in baseball for the past several years, it shouldn't be that surprising that he would get a job as manager, whether with the Brewers or elsewhere. How much of Counsell's success was helped by having Murphy as his bench coach? I imagine the response to his hiring would be much more positive if Counsell had chosen to go anywhere but the Cubs. The thing I'm most curious about is whether the hire is a sign of trades to come and the Brewers taking a step back in 2024 to build for the future or if they choose to keep the core together and try to compete in 2024.