My memory may be hazy, but other than the fact he "claimed" to have made errors on purpose, i don't recall the Sheff years being bad But AL, that's all it takes to be the most hated player in team history (yes, that includes Hammonds). While he wasn't always horrible, can you think of a player doing anything worse (within reason now) on the field than tanking plays. I mean, Hammonds sucked, but he screwed up because he sucked, which is far more acceptable than purposely screwing your team over. All that separated Sheffield from the Chicago Black Sox it that he didn't get paid to tank games, and all of those guys were banished for life. Though I have cooled down since he said that, I thought he should have faced the same fate at the time.