Since July 15, Sheets has pitched one very good game (that masterful August 29 start against the Cubs). His other starts since coming back from injury have been blah, or just downright bad. (He's given up 10 ER in his last 9 IP.) (Actually, I think you could move that date clear back to the end of June. His early July starts, before going on the DL, weren't that hot, either.) So, with the team battling down the stretch for its first playoff berth in 25 years, its number one starter is able to throw one good game in a period of well over two months. I certainly think you can make the argument that that qualifies as a "down" year.