People come to this site to post their thoughts. Unless you have two threads with exactly the same content (f.e. Trade Jenkins) or contains inappropriate comments or language, I see no reason why a thread should be closed. As far as Brewer Fever's post. There was no real thread started about Durrington and Macgruder's role on our team and how we should have improved in that regard. It's a decent topic to bring up. Especially since there is opportunity for different opinions, like my own, that our best prospects are best served playing everyday than once or twice a week. But because someone decided to close a perfectly good thread, I wasn't able to hash out my thoughts on the subject and that is plain annoying. Its the moderator's job to police these threads. It is not their job to decide who's conversation is worthy to be on the site, and who's isn't. That's the elitist attitude that many want to see removed from this site.