The case for Blyleven: I compared Bert to a group of ten Hall of Fame starting pitchers, all of whom were active during his career. The group consists of Bob Gibson, Gaylord Perry, Catfish Hunter, Phil Niekro, Steve Carlton, Fergie Jenkins, Jim Palmer, Tom Seaver, Nolan Ryan and Don Sutton. As with the other players I've examined, I wanted to see how Blyleven compared to his peers who are in the Hall on a per season basis. W=wins, L=losses, CG= complete games, SHO=shutouts, HR= Home Runs Allowed, BB=Walks Allowed, K=strikeouts, ERA=Earned Run Average, S= seasons, 34 starts or 68 relief appearances=1 season S W L CG SHO HR BB K ERA 19.4 15.2 11.8 12.2 2.7 20.2 80.3 161.8 3.13 Group 20.2 14.2 12.3 11.9 2.9 21.2 65.4 183.2 3.31 Blyleven There were 10 Hall of Famers at his position during his career, an average season for the group was 15-12, Bert was 14-12. They threw 12 complete games per season, so did Bert. Blyleven held a slight edge in shutouts, walked 15 fewer batters per season, and struck out 21 more batters per season. Again, these facts are in comparison to 10 elected Hall of Famers from Bert's position, during Bert's era - same ballparks, same rules, same opponents, etc. The man is 5th ever in Ks, and 9th ever in shutouts. Ever...as in 4 guys have more Ks and 8 guys have more shutouts, in over 100 years of play. According to Baseball-Reference.com, 8 of 10 similar pitchers are in the Hall of Fame. 80% of his peers got 75% of the vote or higher. Blyleven's exclusion is absolutely ridiculous.