I did a Hall of Fame Trial for Raines in '05. Prior to that, I had never considered him a Hall of Fame caliber player, but after I compared him to his peers who are in, I changed to a yes vote. First off, when trying to build a control group of Hall of Famers to compare him to, I realized there are very few leadoff types in the Hall from the Post World War II era. To get it done, I had to include Rickey, even though he wasn't in yet, and I had to include Ozzie Smith, based purely on the fact that stolen bases are central to Raines' candidacy, and Smith is among the top HOF base stealers from recent generations. I knew Ozzie's offensive numbers would pull the averages down, but I also knew the positively freakish numbers Rickey put up would offset Ozzie's impact. Here's what I found.... S=seasons, again, 162 games played=1 season S Runs Hits 2B 3B HR RBI SB AVG OPS 15.4 102 169 28 7 11 63 52 .294 .810 Raines 16.7 101 171 29 5 11 62 48 .282 .774 Group The control group is Henderson, Molitor, Brock, Joe Morgan, and Ozzie...Raines is right on them in every category, except for batting average and OPS, where he has a comfortable lead. Among leadoff guys and dominant base stealers....Raines certainly looks like a Hall of Famer to me.