I guess upside-wise, it is an even trade. Hughes could become one of the better pitchers in the game and Cano could continue to put up a .900 ops at 2B. However, given the old adage that there is no such thing as a pitching prospect due to their high flameout rate, getting the #1 pitcher prospect is much different than the #1 hitter prospect. For every Ben Sheets, there are several Edwin Jacksons. I'd feel great about getting a .890 ops 2B is his numbers looked like 300/360/530 where you'd feel confident that if his average started to drop because of bad luck, he'd still be reliable to reach base at a decent clip. If you look at his PECOTA projections going into 2006, Cano exceeded even his most optimistic. So either he improved drastically without improving his plate discipline or he got quite lucky last season. I'd lean toward the latter although I don't really have anything to prove that is the case. Even if Cano had a better walk rate and was putting up a .900 ops, I shy away from trading for a guy when his value is highest, which I think is the case for Cano right now.