I guess it depends on how big of a net one is willing to cast with the term "average." If you go strictly by the median production, no, he might not be. However, I think a valid case can be made that he's certainly just about average. And you have to include the clowns - their production is legitimate production, even if the production was barely legit. For my money, I expect roundabout average production from him next year... I think his batting average is bound to rise some - this is a guess, but even if his BA rises to his career average of .245, he has an average OBP and is closing in on an average SLG. I also think he has the potential to hit maybe 30-40 points higher than '08, and that would put him above average in the OPS department. So part of his averageishness is still potential - almost any upswing at all and he is beyond refute, average. The other piece of this is his defense. As endaround just mentioned, UZR/150 has him below average (they seem to have most 2B at or below average from what I quickly looked through), but most metrics have him at or slightly above average. With more than the UZR data point, I find it tough to argue he's definitely below average defensively and once again I think it's fairly easy to say he's about average, give or take. If he isn't average, are there 8 second basemen in the NL right now that you'd take over him without a second thought? I'd take Utley and Uggla for sure. If Hudson stays in the NL and at 2B, him also. That's three. DeRosa is gone to the AL. Weeks has a significant advantage in OBP over Barmes, Phillips and Sanchez. I'd probably take Kelly Johnson or Rafael Furcal over Rickie, but they're close. Felipe Lopez is about the same. Ronnie Belliard maybe? I have a hard time coming up with eight. He's obviously not in the top tier of second basemen, but he seems to be in and around the large second tier. Finally, FWIW, fangraphs has him with the 6th highest WPA among second basemen last year (and it's a positive number).