Yeah, I agree with a lot of this. I think too often we see a young pitcher performing well for us and envision that it’s going to be that way for the next 6 years when in all likelihood it is not. Call it Tobias Myers or Eric Lauer syndrome. As you say, pitching is fickle and just because a pitcher is pitching like an ace right now doesn’t mean he is one.
I love what Drohan has done for us this year, but who here honestly sees him being in our rotation in 2 years?
Always important to remember that we are trying to buy or sell players based on what we think they will do in the future, not necessarily what they’ve already done.
I may agree or disagree on certain individual moves but in general if the organization trades a player, even for a rental, I’ll trust their judgment on it.