I really worry about the upside/downside of a 6 year/$120 million CC Sabathia contract and I don't think we can afford it. CC would be making 20-25% of the total payroll, even though he only pitches every 5 days. Unless we make the World Series, get an expensive new TV contract, or significantly raise ticket prices, we can't sustain a payroll higher than $90 million. If CC goes down, the Brewers may still compete, but in the long run, they will lose key players that they should have been able to afford. Furthermore, although we are losing $40 million off of our payroll next year, I can come up with a number of increases without factoring in FA signings. -Prince Fielder's arbitration: $8-10 million increase -Corey Hart's new contract/arbitration: ~$5 million increase -Jeff Suppan: $4.5 million increase -Seth McClung/JJ Hardy/Dave Bush's arbitration will also be high if they continue to play well Thus, between our increases and a new CC or Sheets contract, we're back up to our 2008 payroll, and that's without any other new additions. There are only 8 teams that can afford a CC contract. They are the Boston, NY Mets, NY Yankees, Chi Cubs, Chi Sox, LA Dodgers, LA Angels, Atlanta, and Detroit. For a discounted CC or a 4-5 year Sheets contract, you can add another 10 or so teams, including the Brewers. Thus, I advocate letting CC go and trying to sign Sheets to a 5 year deal. They both have essentially the same career ERA, so why not go with Sheets, who will cost significantly less and deliver the same production. Ben has never had a horrible stretch like CC had in April and he certainly can't do any worse than CC did in the playoffs. Plus, he has been living in Milwaukee for years and has a number of ties here, so I think he is much more likely to sign.