Outfield is a position where a lot of players have the statistics to make the All-Star team, as Ely pointed out, but several teams will only get one representative. I think Colorado and Houston will have their only representative at outfield. I tried to play Tony LaRussa put together a roster. I tried not to give any one team too many representatives. I also tried to take the best player on teams with only one representative, even if it was at the expense of a more deserving player at that position (D. Young over A. Gonzalez or D. Lee at 1B). Starters P - Jake Peavy C - Russ Martin 1B - Prince Fielder 2B - Chase Utley 3B - David Wright SS - Jose Reyes OF - Carlos Beltran OF - Ken Griffey Jr. OF - Alfonso Soriano Reserves SP - Brad Penny SP - Chris Young SP - Brandon Webb SP - John Smoltz SP - Ben Sheets SP - Cole Hamels SP - Aaron Harang SP - Ian Snell RP - Francisco Cordero RP - Takashi Saito RP - Jose Valverde C - Brian McCann 1B - Albert Pujols 1B - Dimitri Young 2B - Dan Uggla 2B - Brandon Phillips 3B - Miguel Cabrera 3B - Chipper Jones SS - Hanely Ramirez SS - ?? OF - Matt Holliday OF - Barry Bonds OF - Carlos Lee Washingston is the hardest team to pull a representative from. Zimmerman, Young and C. Cordero are all equally good (bad). Holliday is deserving in my opinion. Houston would either send Oswalt or Lee and starting pitching is a lot more crowded on the roster than outfield. I think a pitcher or two is probably going to be upset that they were left off the roster when the final one is announced. On the roster I made out, I could have easily swapped in Derek Lowe, John Maine, and Trevor Hoffman or any number of other pitchers. What do you think?