I'm not so sure that anyone would want to see Weeks in the 3 spot right now. He is far from our best hitter currently. Despite the historical thinking to the contrary, #3 should not be your best hitter. As has been alluded to before, 2 and 4 are actually more important. Hardy is the perfect 2, and I think Fielder should move to 4. If Gwynn's playing/hot, something like this: Gwynn Hardy Weeks Fielder Hall Jenkins Estrada In Play, Out(s) Or, if you really want to get Weeks out of the top: Gwynn Hardy Hall Fielder Jenkins Estrada Weeks In Play, Out(s)