After reading through numerous threads the past week, I've come to rethink my "In Doug (Melvin, that is) We Trust" mantra. Should we? Has he received more credit than he deserves based on results and the current roster? Nothing fancy here, I just broke the team down into acquisition groups: Draft - I give credit here to Jack Z (whom Melvin did not hire) and his staff Ben Sheets (actually before Jack Z), Manny Parra, Yovanni Gallardo, Prince Fielder, Rickie Weeks, JJ Hardy, Bill Hall, Ryan Braun, Corey Hart, Tony Gwynn Jr Free Agents Eric Gagne, David Riske, Jeff Suppan, Derrick Turnbow, Mike Rivera, Craig Counsell, Joe Dillon, Mike Cameron, Gabe Kapler Via Trade Dave Bush and Gabe Gross (Overbay), Seth McClung (Grant Balfour), Guillermo Mota (Johnny Estrada), Brian Shouse (Enrique Cruz), Salomon Torres (2 minor leaguers), Carlos Villanueva (Wayne Franklin) There is also the matter of Melvin hiring and keeping Ned Yost. The core of the team is obviously the draft choices, which I am (perhaps unfairly) not giving Melvin much credit for. Of the free agent signings, the biggies are Suppan, Gagne and Cameron. The Suppan signing doesn't get too much love here based on the dollars and length. Gagne and Cameron are to be determined, but overall the one-year commitments don't seem too terrible. Riske seems to be a nice signing, but again, he's yet to play for us. Turnbow is the "nugget" who has fallen on more difficult times. And I don't think there was a whole lot of great things to say about the Counsell deal. The best trade at this point is Villanueva for Franklin, so credit to Melvin there. Shouse has turned out well. Bush/Gross (and ZachJack) doesn't seem to be the haul most expected for Overbay, but such is life. Torress could turn out well or just become another "Meh" transaction. There were other trades along the way that - although no players are on the current roster -- have resulted in the Brewers having plenty of early draft picks in 2008. But, based on the current roster, do you think Melvin has held up his end in putting together a winning team? Or should he have done more/better? What is the overall role of the GM and where should we give credit. I'm still a Melvin fan, but....we'll, I'll admit I'm starting to have second thoughts. I'll have to give it some more thought and would like to hear other opinions and comments. (sorry for this poorly written post, but I'm also watching the Wisconsin/Davison game)